These days this isn't in any force at all and I think, maybe, we suffer for it. At least that's the premise I refer to when I find myself being the vocal party addressing some errant child. Yes, I do that. I am the meddling old woman who has something to say and I say it. Not all the time but often enough that a few kids in town and surrounds stop whatever they are doing when they see me coming. They don't usually run away but they get the all suffering look and wait for what is inevitable. Sometimes, just to mix things up, I compliment them. The humor this provokes [mostly mine] is a nice break.
Today I got tired of being ignored by a six year old girl who happens to be Matt's girlfriend's daughter. I pointed out to her that she was being rude. Then I mentioned that responding when she was spoken to was the respectful and polite thing to do. Her mother was standing there so I didn't have to throw in 'the threat'. Mom heard it from the horse's mouth...and didn't immediately interfere. Finally the child looked at me and spoke. Wow! Anyway that got dealt with and I don't think any major feelings were injured in the process.
But the reason I even relate this incident is to ask whether or not you think we, as a society should say anything to children to help straighten their paths or if you feel that should only be the realm visited by the parents.
I say something when I'm the only adult in the area (like when a child litters). Most of the time, they look surprised. Many shape up, but many are fully aware that they don't have to answer to anyone except (maybe) their parents and even that their parents will be happy to tell you to mind your own business if they get the chance.
ReplyDeleteIt leaves the impression that these kids have never been taught manners. That may be true in some cases but for the most part I think they are testing limits to see if they'll get called on it. The alternative is that not only have they never been taught manners but don't have a clue about how [or why they should] go about acquiring them.
DeleteIt's no so much that they've never been "taught" manners; it's that they haven't ever even seen them being used.
DeleteThat's a tough one. For some kids, their parents knowing is a non-threat for them -- their parents may fall into the camp of either not caring or taking offense at anything that could remotely be thought of as criticism of their kid. There are lots of kids in my neighborhood and the bratty ones are pretty much that way no matter what I say to them. The kids in the house behind me are complete brats and follow the lead of their father who's also socially maladjusted, but the parents and kids on either side of me are great.
ReplyDeleteI think maybe the idea of actual parenting is disappearing.
DeleteI say something, and I encourage others to do the same, especially if you can phrase your input in a way that the kid actually gets instruction instead of just being reprimanded.
ReplyDeleteI'd written a longer response, but your blog ate it. LOL
Sorry about my hungry blog page.
DeleteI agree with you about the approach. I try not to be too intimidating.
Parents seem more likely than not to believe their children can do no wrong and resent any criticism of their kid, as someone has said. There aren't any children in my current neighborhood and the houses are far apart so I only know a few of my neighbors. When I worked, I was known in that neighborhood and was more likely to offer help or guidance to children who seemed in need of it.
ReplyDeleteI don't know where or when it changed. When we were kids parents rarely doubted the tales of miniature malfeasance perpetrated by their children [more's the pity from the children's point of view].
DeleteThat is my realm ....
ReplyDelete